|
| |
Averages from each publication
|
|
Date
|
Quarters
|
Type
|
Country
|
ET_MD
|
ET_SD
|
JST_MD
|
JST_SD
|
PTH_MD
|
PTH_SD
|
|
van
Zwolle (transposed Pythagorean)
|
1440
|
1
|
P
|
France
|
7.11
|
8.61
|
15.91
|
21.69
|
4.44
|
10.62
|
|
Erlangen
(anonymous, transposed Pythagorean
|
1475
|
1
|
P
|
Germany
|
6.73
|
8.07
|
10.00
|
15.56
|
10.00
|
15.56
|
|
Ramis
(transposed Pythagorean)
|
1482
|
1
|
P
|
Spain
|
9.09
|
10.99
|
9.82
|
15.28
|
14.18
|
18.65
|
|
Pythagorean
(published by Hugo de Reutlingen)
|
1488
|
1
|
P
|
France
|
7.64
|
9.34
|
20.00
|
26.03
|
0.00
|
0.00
|
|
Grammateus'
|
1518
|
1
|
MMT
|
Germany
|
4.73
|
5.87
|
14.55
|
19.49
|
5.45
|
8.49
|
|
Meantone
(-1/4 Aron)
|
1523
|
1
|
MT
|
Italy
|
13.00
|
15.96
|
6.09
|
7.40
|
20.64
|
25.30
|
|
Fogliano
1-2
|
1529
|
1
|
J
|
Italy
|
15.82
|
19.77
|
4.00
|
9.50
|
22.00
|
28.68
|
|
Agricola
|
1539
|
2
|
J
|
Germany
|
5.82
|
6.75
|
13.82
|
18.18
|
6.18
|
12.07
|
|
Ganassi
(just w/mean semitones)
|
1543
|
2
|
MMT
|
Italy
|
11.36
|
13.53
|
12.27
|
19.06
|
16.45
|
19.62
|
|
Agricola
|
1545
|
2
|
WT
|
Germany
|
8.36
|
9.92
|
15.27
|
22.32
|
4.73
|
9.21
|
|
Bermudo's
Vihuela
|
1555
|
2
|
WT
|
Spain
|
2.59
|
3.62
|
14.10
|
17.70
|
7.25
|
10.38
|
|
Zarlino
(-2/7)
|
1558
|
2
|
MT
|
Italy
|
14.82
|
17.76
|
10.45
|
16.58
|
19.55
|
24.77
|
|
Salinas
(-1/3)
|
1577
|
2
|
MT
|
Spain
|
19.82
|
24.29
|
8.91
|
11.30
|
27.45
|
33.63
|
|
Schneegass
(geometric)
|
1590
|
2
|
MT
|
Germany
|
9.82
|
11.76
|
9.82
|
14.69
|
15.27
|
19.00
|
|
Artusi
1-2
|
1603
|
2
|
MMT
|
Italy
|
6.14
|
7.55
|
13.32
|
17.26
|
11.95
|
14.54
|
|
Reinhard
(just w/mean semitones)
|
1604
|
2
|
MMT
|
Germany
|
8.09
|
10.41
|
10.27
|
17.36
|
12.45
|
16.59
|
|
De
Caus
|
1615
|
2
|
J
|
Germany
|
16.73
|
20.80
|
9.82
|
17.93
|
21.82
|
28.54
|
|
Colonna
1-2
|
1618
|
2
|
MJ
|
Italy
|
18.36
|
25.31
|
11.45
|
20.49
|
21.64
|
31.93
|
|
Kepler
1-2
|
1619
|
2
|
J
|
Germany
|
9.27
|
11.22
|
6.91
|
14.29
|
13.09
|
17.73
|
|
Mersenne
1-2
|
1636
|
3
|
J
|
France
|
13.18
|
16.43
|
10.64
|
19.33
|
15.18
|
21.64
|
|
Mersenne
Improved Meantone 1-2
|
1648
|
3
|
MMT
|
France
|
12.27
|
15.74
|
8.36
|
11.36
|
18.91
|
24.63
|
|
Rossi
1/5 and 2/9
|
1666
|
3
|
MT
|
Italy
|
10.09
|
12.40
|
7.00
|
8.17
|
17.73
|
21.73
|
|
Werckmeister
1-6
|
1691
|
3
|
WT
|
Germany
|
5.54
|
6.74
|
10.98
|
13.92
|
11.73
|
15.14
|
|
Neidhardt's
1st Pub
|
1706
|
3
|
WT
|
Germany
|
2.67
|
3.39
|
12.92
|
16.33
|
9.09
|
11.42
|
|
Malcolm
1-2
|
1721
|
4
|
J
|
England
|
8.23
|
10.23
|
10.23
|
18.87
|
10.41
|
15.00
|
|
Neidhardt's
2nd Pub
|
1724
|
4
|
WT
|
Germany
|
3.55
|
4.12
|
12.09
|
15.15
|
10.45
|
12.78
|
|
Rameau's
Modified Meantone
|
1726
|
4
|
MMT
|
France
|
9.27
|
11.05
|
9.09
|
11.31
|
16.55
|
19.91
|
|
Neidhardt's
3rd Pub
|
1732
|
4
|
MJ
|
Germany
|
7.09
|
8.19
|
10.00
|
14.18
|
12.73
|
16.46
|
|
Bendeler
1-3
|
1739
|
4
|
WT
|
Germany
|
6.00
|
6.79
|
12.06
|
15.25
|
11.45
|
14.75
|
|
Euler
|
1739
|
4
|
J
|
Russia
|
15.27
|
19.12
|
7.64
|
18.78
|
19.64
|
25.71
|
|
Leven
1-2
|
1743
|
4
|
LD
|
France
|
11.14
|
15.80
|
19.59
|
26.87
|
9.50
|
14.51
|
|
Silbermann
(-1/6)
|
1748
|
4
|
MT
|
Germany
|
6.18
|
7.52
|
8.91
|
11.02
|
13.82
|
16.86
|
|
Harrison
(-3/10)
|
1749
|
4
|
MT
|
England
|
17.00
|
20.86
|
7.18
|
8.97
|
24.64
|
30.20
|
|
Smith
(5/18)
|
1749
|
4
|
MT
|
England
|
15.27
|
18.68
|
6.55
|
7.95
|
22.91
|
28.01
|
|
Gallimard's
Modified Meantone 1-2
|
1754
|
4
|
MMT
|
France
|
10.64
|
12.51
|
9.27
|
11.31
|
17.45
|
21.34
|
|
Montvallon
|
1758
|
4
|
J
|
France
|
8.55
|
10.45
|
6.00
|
12.05
|
14.00
|
18.41
|
|
Rousseau
|
1768
|
4
|
J
|
France
|
17.09
|
22.61
|
11.64
|
25.19
|
20.00
|
27.52
|
|
Marpurg's
Pub
|
1776
|
4
|
WT
|
Poland
|
5.06
|
6.42
|
10.85
|
14.60
|
10.94
|
14.06
|
|
Mercadier
(1/12,1/6)
|
1777
|
4
|
WT
|
France
|
4.18
|
4.88
|
11.64
|
14.72
|
10.73
|
13.63
|
|
Kirnberger
1&3
|
1779
|
4
|
WT
|
Germany
|
7.36
|
8.65
|
9.18
|
13.86
|
12.30
|
16.85
|
|
Vallotti
Circulating
|
1781
|
4
|
WT
|
Italy
|
4.73
|
5.87
|
10.91
|
14.28
|
12.00
|
14.59
|
|
von
Wiese 1-3
|
1793
|
4
|
WT
|
Germany
|
5.61
|
6.82
|
12.94
|
17.47
|
7.06
|
11.83
|
|
Young
1-2
|
1800
|
4
|
WT
|
England
|
5.45
|
6.58
|
10.73
|
14.20
|
11.82
|
15.22
|
|
Stanhope
(1/3 comma)
|
1806
|
4
|
WT
|
England
|
7.00
|
8.44
|
9.18
|
13.86
|
12.27
|
16.74
|
|
ET_MD
=Equal Temperament Standard, Mean Deviation
|
|
ET_SD
=Equal Temperament Standard, Standard Deviation
|
|
JST_MD=Just
Intonation Standard, Mean Deviation
|
|
JST_SD
=Just Intonation Standard, Standard Deviation
|
|
PTH_MD=Pythagorean
Standard, Mean Deviation
|
|
PTH_SD=Pythagorean
Standard, Standard Deviation
|
|
|
|